If there’s one thing we can all agree on, it’s that chocolate makes everything better. Whether you're a devoted chocoholic, searching for the perfect gift, or just looking to treat yourself (because you deserve it!), Central Ohio is home to some of the most delicious, drool-worthy chocolate shops around. In January of 2025, we polled more than 135,000 members of our Facebook Group. Thanks our voters, we’ve ranked the best chocolate shops in Columbus.
Here are the top picks, as chosen by our dedicated chocolate lovers.
#10. Marie’s Candies
A shop with history and heart, Marie’s Candies has been creating fine chocolates and unique gifts since 1956.
They make everything in small batches to guarantee freshness and quality, and their shop is located in a restored train depot, making it one of the most charming places to satisfy your sweet tooth.
#9. Lohcally Artisan Chocolates
If chocolate was art, this shop would be a museum. 🎨🍫
Located in Powell, Lohcally Artisan Chocolates specializes in hand-painted chocolates. Every piece is a mini masterpiece, almost too beautiful to eat (but, let’s be real, you’re gonna eat it anyway).
#8. Wittich’s Candy Shop
This place has been around since 1840! That makes it the oldest family-owned and operated candy shop in the entire country. (Yes, really.) 🇺🇸
Located in Circleville, Wittich’s is a step back in time, where candies are still made in small batches with no preservatives. They even have an old-school soda fountain, making it one of the coolest chocolate stops around.
#7. Candy Cottage
Sometimes, the best chocolate comes with a little nostalgia. The Candy Cottage legacy dates back to the 1960s, and they’ve been serving up fresh roasted peanuts, handmade chocolates, and mints in small batches ever since.
If you’re looking for a shop with heart, history, and high-quality treats, this is the place.
#6. Schmidt's Fudge Haus
Nestled in German Village, Schmidt’s Fudge Haus is THE place for fudge lovers. Their old-fashioned process includes copper kettles and marble tables, because when you’re making legendary chocolate, you do it the right way.
They also have a little thing called Schmurtles—aka chocolate-covered peanut butter turtles. These little bites of heaven are a must-try!
#5. Eagles Family Candy Co.
A true family tradition, Eagles Family Candy Co. is a fourth-generation chocolatier that still makes their chocolates in-house.
Their time-honored recipes ensure exceptional quality and rich flavors, making them a must-visit spot for chocolate lovers in Central Ohio.
#4. Winans Coffee & Chocolates
If you love coffee AND chocolate, Winans is basically your dream come true. ☕ + 🍫 = ❤️
They’ve been handcrafting chocolates since the 1960s and are known for their decadent Buckeyes, rich truffles, and legendary Wurtles® (which, if you don’t know, are basically the best caramel-chocolate-nut combo ever created).
And let’s not forget their coffee! If you love a perfectly roasted cup of joe, you can pair it with your chocolates for the ultimate indulgence.
#3. Pure Imagination Chocolatier
Ever wondered what it would be like to eat chocolate in France, Italy, or Belgium? No need to book a plane ticket—just visit Pure Imagination Chocolatier in Grandview Heights.
Their truffles are legendary, and some say they might just be the best in the entire state. (Actually, Yelp officially called them Ohio’s Best Chocolate Shop in 2022, so we’d say that’s a solid endorsement.)
Every piece of chocolate is handmade right in the shop, and with each bite, you can taste the love, craftsmanship, and maybe a little bit of magic.
#2. Chocolate Café
This isn’t just a chocolate shop—it’s a chocolate EXPERIENCE.
Whether you’re stopping in for brunch, lunch, or dinner, or just want to sip on a rich, elegant chocolate drink, Chocolate Café is the place to be.
But let’s talk about their Chocolate Cake Martini for a second. Yes, that’s a real thing. Yes, it’s just as decadent as it sounds. And yes, you should definitely try it.
From handmade chocolates to dreamy desserts, this is the place where chocolate fantasies come true.
#1. Anthony-Thomas Chocolates
If you’ve lived in Central Ohio for more than five minutes, you’ve probably heard of Anthony-Thomas Chocolates. A true local legend, this family-owned and operated business has been perfecting chocolate since 1952! With 13 locations across Central Ohio, they make sure your chocolate cravings are never too far away.
And if you love watching chocolate being made (because who doesn't?), they even offer factory tours where you can witness the magic firsthand.
Best Chocolate in central Ohio -Final Thoughts
You can’t go wrong with ANY of these chocolate shops. Every single one brings something special to the table—whether it’s legendary hand-dipped Buckeyes, old world fudge, rich hand-crafted truffles, nostalgic candies, or the perfect coffee-chocolate combo.
So, grab your chocolate-loving bestie or just yourself (self-care, baby!) and start tasting your way through the Best Chocolate Shops in Central Ohio.
And hey, if you visit any of these, tag Columbus Foodies on social media and let us know what you tried!
What are you waiting for? It's time to eat!
Surveys are conducted via the Columbus Foodies Facebook Group with more than 138,000 members (and growing). Wal Ozello is a Senior Partner of Columbus Foodies. Make sure to check out our Columbus Foodies Discount Card to get savings at more than 100 restaurants around Central Ohio.
Comentarios