Central Ohio is home to some of the best burger joints, serving everything from classic diner-style patties to gourmet creations. In October of 2024, we polled more than 130,000 members of the Columbus Foodies Facebook Group. Thanks to their votes, we’ve ranked the the Top 10 Hamburger Restaurants in Central Ohio. Ready to find your next favorite burger spot? Let’s dig in, starting with a five-way tie for #10!
10. Gahanna Grill
For decades, the Gahanna Grill has been a go-to spot for locals craving a classic burger. Their famous “Beast Burger” is a must-try, featuring a half-pound of juicy beef topped with all the fixings. This spot offers a cozy, neighborhood feel that pairs perfectly with their satisfying menu.
10. Ringside Café
Step into Columbus’ oldest bar, serving up great burgers in a boxing-themed setting. The “Undisputed Champ Burger” is a knockout, loaded with cheese, crispy bacon, and their signature Ringside Sauce. It’s the perfect place for burger lovers and history buffs alike.
10. O'Reilly's Pub
A no-frills dive bar with some seriously good burgers. O’Reilly’s is all about laid-back vibes and comfort food done right. Their juicy burgers, paired with a cold pint, make for a classic experience.
10. Cooper’s Hawk Winery & Restaurant
Known for its refined dining atmosphere, Cooper’s Hawk serves up a premium burger experience. Don't be fooled by their fine dining atmosphere, the burgers here are delicious. Their gourmet burgers pair perfectly with a glass of wine from their extensive collection, making it a unique spot for burger and wine lovers.
10. Press Grill / Press Pub
Nestled in the Short North, Press Grill’s burgers are simple yet satisfying. The “Press Burger,” served with crispy fries, is the ultimate comfort food. It’s the ideal place to grab a bite before exploring the vibrant neighborhood.
9. Club 185
This German Village favorite is a cozy bar serving up top-notch burgers. The “Club Burger” is a classic—juicy beef, fresh toppings, and a side of their famous onion rings. It’s a burger that’s sure to hit the spot every time.
8. Pat and Gracie’s Tavern & Garage
Named after the original owners of the land where their first restaurant stands, Pat and Gracie’s combines local history with delicious food. Their burgers are made from Ohio-raised beef, and the “Gracie’s Classic Burger” is a fan favorite.
7. Arch City Tavern
Arch City Tavern is the perfect blend of rustic charm and modern cuisine. Their burgers are gourmet creations, featuring high-quality beef and inventive toppings. The “Arch City Burger,” topped with bacon jam and smoked cheddar, is a must-try.
6. Ritzy’s
A throwback to classic diners, Ritzy’s serves up smash burgers with a side of nostalgia. Their crispy-edged patties are cooked to perfection, and their hand-spun milkshakes make the perfect companion to any meal.
5. Flipside Burgers and Shakes
Flipside takes burgers to the next level with Ohio grass-fed beef and gourmet toppings. Try their “Truffle Burger,” topped with truffle aioli, arugula, and smoked gouda. Pair it with one of their creamy milkshakes for the ultimate indulgence.
4. Northstar Café
Known for its commitment to organic and locally sourced ingredients, Northstar Café serves a burger unlike any other. Their signature “Northstar Burger” features a blend of brisket and beef, offering a flavor profile that’s rich, unique, and unforgettable.
3. Preston’s - A Burger Joint
Preston’s is a Clintonville favorite, celebrated for its smashburgers. These thin, crispy-edged patties are packed with flavor. The “Preston Burger,” loaded with special sauce, lettuce, and pickles, is a burger lover’s dream.
2. Hamburger Inn Diner
Located in Delaware, Ohio, this classic diner serves fresh, never-frozen Black Angus beef burgers with hand-cut fries. The “Big Hamburger Inn Burger” is a throwback to simpler times, offering a taste of nostalgia with every bite.
1. Thurman’s Café
No list of best burgers in Central Ohio would be complete without Thurman’s. Located in the heart of German Village, Thurman’s is legendary for its massive, mouthwatering burgers. The “Thurmanator,” a ¾-pound burger piled high with toppings, is the ultimate burger experience and a must-try for anyone visiting Columbus.
These burger spots represent the best of Central Ohio’s food scene, offering something for every type of burger lover. Whether you’re into gourmet creations, classic diner vibes, or smashburgers, there’s a spot on this list for you. What are you waiting for? It’s time to eat!
Surveys are conducted via the Columbus Foodies Facebook Group with more than 135,000 members. Wal Ozello is a Senior Partner of Columbus Foodies. Make sure to check out our Columbus Foodies Discount Card to get savings at more than 75 restaurants around Central Ohio.