Central Ohio's food scene is on fire and nothing has more variety and different tastes than our pizza. From our unique Columbus-style pizzas to "imports" from New York City, Cleveland, Youngstown, Chicago, and others, we have it all. In September of 2024, we polled more than 130,000 members of our Columbus Foodies Facebook Group to hear about their favorite Central Ohio pizza shops. Our group was passionate about Central Ohio pizza. Here are their top ten favorites.
10. Grandad's Pizza
With multiple locations throughout Central Ohio, Grandad's Pizza has been serving the Columbus area with dedication and pride. Their menu boasts a variety of specialty pizzas, subs, and comfort foods that cater to diverse tastes. The family-owned restaurants emphasize quality ingredients and friendly service, making it a go-to for many locals.
A Central Ohio tradition since 1952, Tommy's Pizza is known for its thin, cracker-like crust that achieves a perfect crispness. Seriously, it's like eating a pizza cracker. With locations in Upper Arlington and Dublin, this establishment has been a staple for generations, offering a consistent and delightful pizza experience. Their OSU campus location closed in 2024, but it was a university staple for generations.
Established in 1954, Rubino's Pizza in Bexley is celebrated for its crunchy thin crust and old-school atmosphere. This place is an OLD SCHOOL pizza place. No online ordering and cash-only! They serve water and canned soda, emphasizing a straightforward, nostalgic dining experience that has stood the test of time.
If you like your pepperoni so crispy that it curls up on it's edges then Sexton's Pizza is the place for you. Started in 2016 by two veteran brothers, they seek to make the crunchiest pizza in Columbus. Their dedication to quality and flavor has earned them a loyal following among Columbus pizza enthusiasts.
Serving the North End of Columbus for over 60 years, Terita's Pizza is an Italian family-owned and operated pizzeria. They make their own Italian sausage with no fillers and source the rest of their ingredients from top-area suppliers.
If you're craving classic New York-style pizza, Borgata Pizza Café delivers with perfection. Their handmade pasta and use of fresh, local ingredients elevate the dining experience. Plus, Columbus Foodies Discount Card members can enjoy a 10% discount, adding value to every visit.
If you like specialty pizzas, this is the place for you. Since 2007, JT's Pizza & Pub has been serving up some of the best pizza in Columbus. With options to choose from four different sauces, a variety of cheeses, and a plethora of specialty pizzas, they offer a customizable pizza experience that caters to individual preferences.
A Columbus institution for over 60 years, The Pizza House is known for its unique combination of fluffy yet crispy pizza. Their dedication to homemade recipes and accommodating service has solidified their place in the hearts of many pizza lovers.
A beloved Columbus favorite, Hounddog's Pizza is famous for its spicy pizza sauces and the signature Smokin’ Joe’s crust. Their commitment to bold flavors and a vibrant atmosphere continues to attract both new and returning patrons.
1. Adriatico’s
Crowned as the top pizza place, Adriatico’s offers a super thick crust reminiscent of garlic bread, topped with delicious sauce and generous portions of toppings. Serving great pizza for over 38 years, their recognition for excellence is well-deserved, making it a must-visit for any pizza aficionado.
Congratulations to all these restaurants for making the list of the best pizzas in Central Ohio. Whether you're a fan of thin crust, thick crust, spicy sauces, or traditional flavors, this list offers something for every palate. Embark on a culinary journey and discover your personal favorite among Columbus's best pizza shops.
What are you waiting for? It's time to eat!
Surveys are conducted via the Columbus Foodies Facebook Group with more than 135,000 members.
Comments